FansOfAll
loopop
loopop

patreon


DAW-less DAW? Producing a full track with vocals on Verselab MV-1

Hi!

When I first saw the MV-1 Verselab from Roland, I was hesitant to review it - it's designed to produce vocals-based songs: I've heard myself sing, and I didn't like what I heard (though with auto tune I'm a darn good robot!).

MV-1 seems like a real attempt to create a DAWless-DAW. Maschine, Deluge and AKAI Force already have arranger based sequencing options fully capable of producing full tracks. MV-1 ditches the real time performance features to focus on making arranger style song production as simple as possible.

It seems like Roland are marketing it as a hip-hop/rap production station (the default BPM is 70 and the default kit it very trap) - and, while I have a lot of love for the genre, I completely lack the talent.

But then I remembered a track a good friend of mine wrote, produced and never published anywhere. I asked her for the vocal stem, and took upon myself to reproduce the track in MV-1, as a challenge to whether MV-1 can be used to produce a "real" song, which was produced on a DAW, with no real orientation towards "electronic music". Plus it was a good opportunity to force her to publish the song somewhere...

I've attached my direct mixdown export from MV-1 to this post.

Hopefully, my reproduction does her version justice! Here's a link to her bandcamp if you want to listen to the original, and if you like what you hear, please leave her a nice comment!

Have a great weekend!

Ziv (unfortunately still not rapping on youtube as "Loopop"...)

DAW-less DAW? Producing a full track with vocals on Verselab MV-1

Comments

maschine now supports clips in the arranger and is a serious competitor to this

I think you underestimate the cost of the physical hardware controls, R&D and bundled content, but I agree with you that someone should, and I promise you I'll cover it when they do cause I'd love me one of those, but for some reason, no one does. Regarding me using a prepared stem, 16 parts etc - all of those are disclosed in the video and as I mentioned to another commenter in the video, there are cons throughout and 5 minutes of cons at the end compared to 30 seconds of pros. I still had a ton of fun making the track compared to using a DAW though. My recommendation would be a DAW too, this is for people who don't want or are intimidated to use one - we take for granted using a DAW and sometimes forget how intimidating it is to get one set up and use.

Again, under horsepowered, no undo. Today, when a Rasberry Pi 4 with 8GB and a quadcore processor costs $75 retail, someone should be able to put together a "portastudio" that is easy to use, can manage long audio stems, has decent efx and instruments, and allows for punching in and comping. These are things that songwriters and producers really need. And (as much as I love you and your channel) your comparison by taking vocal stems from the original session leaves out all of the comping, splicing, de-essing, compression and eq-ing that goes into making them. Finally, what happens when you hit the wall? When your track needs that 17th part? Can you export the project as stems to be put into a DAW? My recommendation to people who are considering it: A cheap windows laptop, Reaper, a decent audio interface, and a good mic. In the future 3 /4 of those things will still have value. The Verselab will be an expensive paperweight.


More Creators