Random Poll #14 : Names
Added 2025-02-17 21:53:42 +0000 UTCLast poll. Chapters as usual from tomorrow.
This poll is in regards to the original story I'm working on. In fanfics, I'll just follow the pattern used in the original story, sort of like how I used Japanese names in this story.
Anyway, I've been wondering which names I should use in the book I write. It'll most likely be a cultivation novel (still in works, will take several years to sort out all the details). So far, I've only read Chinese cultivation novels. But, I have no desire to use Chinese names. The reason is simply because it's very difficult to remember them 🥲 Even the novels I read, I mostly remembered characters by the short form of their names (like first letter of each name, surname and anything else).
I haven't read any Western cultivation novels, so I would like to hear what they usually follow if any of you have read some.
My first idea was to just randomly use the names from various cultures. However, that could make the reading a bit incoherent.
The next idea was to use only Japanese or only Western names so that I won't have to think too much about it.
However, later on, I had more ideas. The one I find most appealing right now is to use names from different cultures in different parts of the world, sort of like the real world. There could be some mix up, either due to immigration/travelling/or just parents giving exotic/cool names to their children, but names in a region will generally stay consistent.
This can also allow me to replicate some real world cultural aspects in those regions. I guess the only other story (I read) that has something similar is One Piece, where names from several cultures are used.
One complication I faced here was what to do when I do a world expansion (either going beyond the planet or to a higher realm). If I stay with just one culture, I could maintain similar names for the people on other planets/higher realm.
However, if I use several cultures, then it might not make sense to give them names from the cultures I have used previously in the story (though there could be some exceptions).
This isn't particularly difficult to handle as we have way too many cultures and I could just use some lesser known cultures for them. That said, it creates another issue. Since most of the characters will suddenly have names from a whole new culture, it may feel strange (not entirely sure what it'll feel like as I don't think I have ever read something like this).
So, I'd like to know what your thoughts are on this matter. Which name patterns would you like to see in a new story you start to read?
PS: I suppose a similar logic can be applied to language, but giving different regions different languages will complicate storytelling way too much, especially once aliens/higher beings are introduced. I'll stick to the English language to avoid all those complexities (though I suppose I could make a few rare exceptions if need be).
Comments
👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-19 13:43:41 +0000 UTCFor the primary world use different cultures names for different regions but of the same country and for higher/other worlds use same method but of different countries then the one used for primary world for example primary world india world-2 america, world-3 africa, and so on
Brij Parmar
2025-02-19 12:36:54 +0000 UTCU know cultivation is a culture as well...so if u want to keep it basic cultivation is what everyone has in common so they can share many similarities
Kwabena Kumi
2025-02-18 19:29:58 +0000 UTCGood point. Thanks :)
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 19:21:56 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 19:21:33 +0000 UTCLol 😆
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 19:21:12 +0000 UTCNo plans to go wirh Chinese names (unless may be 1 or 2 odd ones). That's why I didn't include them in the options 😅
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 19:20:50 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:28:27 +0000 UTCUnderstandable. I would recommend audiobooks if you have less time, then you can listen to it in bite-sizes whenever you’re doing something else like cleaning, cooking or exercising. The audiobooks of The Stormlight Archives also have really good voice actors. The first part of the first book is free on Brandon’s YT channel, it’s 7 hours long, so you can try it before buying the whole book.
Greedsmith
2025-02-18 17:14:15 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:02:29 +0000 UTCAlright 👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:02:14 +0000 UTC💀
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:01:48 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:01:41 +0000 UTCSame 🤣
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:01:13 +0000 UTCToday's chapter? In a few minutes.
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:00:59 +0000 UTCInteresting idea :)
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 17:00:25 +0000 UTCThanks :)
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:59:59 +0000 UTCFew mins
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:59:14 +0000 UTCTy fot the idea :) Will save it to see if I can come up with something with this. Anyway, creating an original story is a lot difficult than I first thought. I'm done a bit with the geography and the power system, but both still need a lot of work. And have to work on lot of plots and creating a lore. It'll likely take several years before I'm confident in starting to write it. In the mean time, I'll be writing fanfics, so don't worry :)
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:57:14 +0000 UTCTrue
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:54:11 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:53:36 +0000 UTCEta?
Sevensins
2025-02-18 16:53:29 +0000 UTCHaven't had the time to read much lately 🥲
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:53:24 +0000 UTCHmm, yeah. That could work.
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:53:07 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:52:42 +0000 UTC👍
Devil Hex
2025-02-18 16:52:36 +0000 UTC@DevilHex Theres two novels you should read the wiki on for ideas. Ascension of the Immortal Asura and Journey of the Fate Destroying Emperor. The 1st one straight up uses Western and non-traditional eastern names and this makes remembering the characters way easier. I also generally recommend this novel. Its pretty simple and straightforward in its story, but literally none of annoying bs from novels similar to it. The 2nd is a great blend of diversity. Western, Buddhism, taoism, etc. However it doesn't just use different hemes simply for convenient power ups but incorporates them into the story so they hold actual weight for both the mc and the world around him. I also really recommend this novel, probably one of my favorites ever. First 40 or so chapters or rough due to the authors inexperience, but after that, it just gets better and better.
kash_kxng
2025-02-18 16:02:42 +0000 UTCCan't figure out how to start a new line on mobile, so sorry if it's awkward to read! Maybe something along the lines of 3 different name types for 3 different cultures/races? Then we get to the higher realm and find out that there's 7 total types there, the 4 ones we were missing were killed off thousands of years ago. Every lower realm starts off with 7 at their beginning, but over time some or most of the cultures get killed off. That way every lower realm can have myriad differences and histories. Perhaps even something like realms with 3 or less cultures start fighting each other based on traits like eye color, skin color, region, or how close someone lives to mountains. But when they're in the higher realms there's too many hostile enemies to have open infighting wars and organizations/lands gather together around culture/race
LuNaR
2025-02-18 08:07:32 +0000 UTCOi, sem pressa mas pode dar alguma estimativa de quando vai lançar de novo? A dúvida fica me corroendo
Gray
2025-02-18 08:01:32 +0000 UTCNames can be so tricky! I'm so grateful when we get nicknames in Chinese and Korean novels.
LuNaR
2025-02-18 07:47:11 +0000 UTCBro ngl western names are underrated and under used when it comes to cultivation novels. It also gets wayyy easier to remember names that are named after pop culture things, like pikachu for a rat or chad for a cool guy, hell even a slave merchant named diddy
Jonnylawz0
2025-02-18 07:30:47 +0000 UTCIn a novel called Arcane Academy there is a sort of cultivation power up method most of the names are american (the culture is also somewhat western) Same with Supreme harem god cultivation system (which if u take out the sex scenes is one of the most fun novels ive read) I believe going with whatever feels comfortable to u is the best
David Rafael Tamir
2025-02-18 07:06:43 +0000 UTCWhen it comes to Chinese/Japanese names, I find it hard to keep track of unless they're a long term character. I think the different places/cultures makes more sense and is better. When it comes to a higher world naming it depends on the world. Like is the earth's culture tied to the higer world in anyway? Or did people ascend from the lower world to there or vice versa. Is there a demon world and can you take naming from religion or mythology?
Jack
2025-02-18 05:47:00 +0000 UTCso I'm not Asian, for me, some Chinese names for example are hard to memorize because I am not used to them and this sometimes confuses me in stories. I end up having to go back in the story to see who that person is, especially when the names are similar like Xian or Xi or Lala lulu Lili, something like that. But I understand that lots of the readers do not face this issue, that is why I believe perhaps a mix of both would be best because it doesn't make sense for an Asian character based in Asia to have a western or Arabic name, perhaps for ease of remembering, do not make them too similar with only a letter difference or write the first name then last instead of last before first, basically anything to set them apart.
Ahmad Ayoubi
2025-02-18 04:56:57 +0000 UTC"Creating heavenly laws" is another example of a very large world/universe written as a small one to make it digestible...introduce the immensity of it but start from the main character in the beginning and expand outwards..if u want to stick with japanese names/or western that's fine its bout ur comfortability as an author u tell the audience what the culture is versus us creating our own idea then critiquing it as though we are writing
Kwabena Kumi
2025-02-18 04:25:10 +0000 UTCAlso keep the world small in the beginning then expanded it along the way...if u introduce the world in terms of the real world and not regions it can get out of control... "absolute resonance"(great story)...there is the outer continent and inner continent the names are Japanese with a simplified map u can have all western or Japanese names with no complaints if u have different world continents then u have to change culture names to tell the difference
Kwabena Kumi
2025-02-18 04:14:05 +0000 UTCLike Dalvin in Immortal simulation
Tristan Cercado
2025-02-18 04:03:03 +0000 UTC1 of the things that I think would help is keep it manageable...dont over populate cultures..easier to remember when u dont have to think of a 20 different culture names..maximum 5 is manageable without headaches
Kwabena Kumi
2025-02-18 03:59:15 +0000 UTCI've read many cultivation stories. Some of them use primarily common American names. My current favorite story is one. Out of respect for DH I won't mention it, but I'm not concerned with names unless they don't match the setting. For example, if the story setting is an alternative ancient China don't name your mc Jonathan. But if it's post apocalyptic America, go for it.
Jaimenz
2025-02-18 01:41:20 +0000 UTCfrom what I've read, some authors in their first books rack their brains by changing names and putting names that follow the world they are writing, but after many books they write the name directly as they want without following the world they are writing in anymore
Zaoprimo
2025-02-18 00:35:06 +0000 UTCOhh almost forgot. Profane prince of domination is a western cultivation novel with names that depend on the culture. There were Indian names for Hindu gods, some nordic names and other western names. To be honest I also would prefer not to read something with Chinese names, because after some time of not seeing them you don’t remember most of the supporting character names.
BLazeSavage
2025-02-17 23:37:30 +0000 UTCExactly
Greedsmith
2025-02-17 23:09:27 +0000 UTCI love Mr. Carcinisation 😂
Greedsmith
2025-02-17 23:08:33 +0000 UTCI voted for "Mostly Western names". ... I don't know if I'm happy or sad about this news about an original novel of yours. I say happy because you're a good author, I've really enjoyed the fanfic you created, Fujin is an excellent MC and you managed to delve very well into the development of the world. The original author of Naruto left many gaps and lost information about many things and so far you've managed to cover them, such as new continents, the logic of Fuinjutsu and Juinjutsu, the clans of Konoha. I've always wanted to know what happened to the Senju clan, but nothing is said in Canon and you showed this and much more in your work. I say sad because I wanted to read another fanfic created by you too, something like Hunter x Hunter that already has a much better power base and world than Naruto's. I think if you like that story (HxH), you could create a fanfic as good as your current one. ... I'd like to make a suggestion about adding Cultivation to the current work. Paste the comment below into a markdown preview for a more readable and organized comment, like this one: https://markdownlivepreview.com/ # Introducing Cultivation into the Naruto World Introducing Cultivation (Xianxia/Wuxia) into the Naruto universe can be done in a coherent way by leveraging existing concepts such as chakra, natural energy (Senjutsu), and chakra pathways (meridians). Here’s how it could work while staying true to Naruto’s world logic. --- ## 1. Cultivation Fundamentals in Naruto ### 1.1. World Energy and Absorption - In Naruto, there is already a concept similar to Qi absorption, which is Natural Energy, used in Senjutsu. - This energy permeates the environment and can be absorbed by those with refined chakra control, such as Sage Mode users. - Chakra in Naruto is formed by the fusion of: - Physical Energy (from the body) - Spiritual Energy (from the mind) - A Ninja Cultivator could learn to absorb and refine world energy, increasing their power and strengthening their body. ### 1.2. The Dantian in Naruto - Since there is no mention of a Dantian, it can be introduced as a structure formed through cultivation. - Two possible approaches: 1. Naturally Created through Cultivation – The ninja must strengthen their body and chakra pathways first until they can condition their energy to open the Dantian. 2. Created through Fūinjutsu or Juinjutsu – The ninja engraves a special seal on themselves, forcing the formation of the Dantian as a container for refined chakra. > 📌 Important Detail: Just like in many cultivation novels, the Dantian does not exist physically—it is an "internal void" accessible only to those who have opened it. Even dissecting a body would not reveal it. --- ## 2. Cultivation Stages in Naruto We can create cultivation stages inspired by traditional Xianxia systems but adapted to the ninja world. ### 2.1. Body Refinement (Initial Stage) - Before opening the Dantian, the ninja must strengthen their body to withstand higher levels of chakra. - This includes extreme physical training and exercises that expand the chakra pathways. 🔹 Naruto Parallel: Ninjas like Might Guy and Rock Lee, who train their bodies to the limit, already practice a primitive version of this stage. --- ### 2.2. Opening the Dantian (Formation of the Chakra Core) - Once the body and meridians are strong enough, the ninja can begin refining natural energy and attempt to direct it to create the Dantian. - This can be done naturally or accelerated through sealing techniques (Fūinjutsu). 🔹 Naruto Parallel: This is somewhat similar to Sage Mode training, where the user learns to absorb natural energy without turning into stone. --- ### 2.3. Ninja Cultivation Stages After opening the Dantian, we can introduce cultivation levels based on chakra mastery and natural energy refinement. #### 1. Chakra Foundation Stage (Base Formation Realm) - The cultivator still depends on regular chakra but can now absorb natural energy. - Mastery of chakra circulation in the meridians (chakra pathways) is crucial. #### 2. Chakra Core Formation (Golden Core Realm) - The energy inside the Dantian solidifies, making chakra denser and purer. - Ninjas at this stage can access a superior version of Sage Mode. #### 3. Dao Manifestation of Chakra (Nascent Soul Realm) - The cultivator begins to understand and manipulate fundamental ninja world laws. - Techniques such as Rinnegan, Perfect Senjutsu, and reality-altering abilities appear at this stage. #### 4. Chakra Enlightenment (Immortal Ascension) - The user becomes a transcendent being, capable of creating and modifying realities with pure chakra. - This would be the level of Kaguya Otsutsuki and Hagoromo Otsutsuki, who master space-time laws. --- ## 3. How Ninja Cultivators Differ from Regular Ninjas ### 3.1. Differences Between a Regular Ninja and a Cultivator Ninja | Attribute | Traditional Ninja | Cultivator Ninja | |--------------|------------------|-----------------| | Chakra | Created by physical and spiritual energy fusion | Refined continuously, making it purer and stronger | | Power Growth | Relies on training and jutsus | Grows by refining energy and unlocking Dantian stages | | Use of Natural Energy | Only accessible with Senjutsu | Can absorb passively | | Lifespan | Limited by physical endurance | Cultivators can extend their lifespan | ### 3.2. The Four Cultivator Ninja Schools To diversify the Ninja Cultivation system, we can introduce different cultivation schools based on distinct chakra philosophies. 1. Body Cultivation School – Focuses on physical enhancement, treating the body as a weapon (similar to the Otsutsuki). 2. Sealing School – Uses advanced Fūinjutsu to store and refine energy, accelerating cultivation. 3. Soul Cultivation School – Explores spiritual pathways, allowing techniques related to immortality and reincarnation. 4. Elemental Cultivation School – Specializes in extreme elemental manipulation through chakra refinement. --- ## 4. How This Would Affect Naruto’s Story If this concept were introduced, we could expect major changes, such as: 1. Regular ninjas would be no match for advanced cultivators. 2. Battles would rely more on pure energy manipulation than just jutsus. 3. Immortality could be achieved without Edo Tensei or Rinnegan. 4. Otsutsukis would no longer be the only "gods" of the ninja world. 5. Master-disciple relationships would become more central, as knowledge transmission would be vital for cultivation. --- ## Conclusion The introduction of Cultivation into the Naruto world can be done without breaking the universe’s logic, utilizing existing concepts such as chakra, natural energy, Fūinjutsu, and Senjutsu. The Dantian could be created through cultivation or sealing techniques, and Ninja Cultivators could achieve higher power levels through continuous refinement. If you want to expand this idea further, you can create exclusive techniques, advanced bloodlines, and even a new system of clans based on cultivation! And it is possible to add possible cultivators (humans) in some other distant continent, they would not be very advanced in cultivation knowledge, since cultivation in this world of Naruto is still in the early stages and the clans of certain summoned animals, such as the winged saber-toothed ones, have a certain connection with cultivation methods... something that Fujin could improve with different/more advanced approaches because he has a more comprehensive perspective (ideas, knowledge) of cultivation for being a geek in his past life... I hope you like it, I think it would be great to add cultivation to this fanfic and it would give you experience in writing a cultivation novel for your next original novel.
Aetherist
2025-02-17 23:06:28 +0000 UTCThe higher realms issue is pretty simple in my mind. You would think that the lower realms originate from the higher realms, meaning that they had the same cultures at some point. Then there’s also the fact that some really talented people from the lower realms would find ways to travel to the higher realms, meaning that their cultures would be injected into the higher realms (assuming that they’re strong enough to become trend-setters😂). In some stories, the higher realms control the lower realms (to a certain extent), that could also be an explanation for having similar cultures. P.S. This week actually went by pretty quickly, I thought that it would feel longer. I can’t wait for this new post-timeskip arc 😆
Greedsmith
2025-02-17 23:06:23 +0000 UTCComplex subject and perhaps the reason why I'm not particularly attracted to cultivation novels, although I have suffered through some manhuas and manhwas where it is difficult for me to remember who is who because sometimes only one syllable is the distinction between one character or another, I would stay if it shows different cultures that the name is a reflection would be something that makes the world very immersive. It would be strange for example in a medieval world to find a Satoru Goujo, but who is an inhabitant of that world and region. I have seen some names with Abramic roots in Korea but they are almost oriented in a modern world, like David, Miguel, Luis etc. And I know something oriental but a western name comes out as if nothing would be strange XD, unless it is a westerner who by accident enters a cultivation world and his name remains as his situation someone who is out of place.
Rubén López
2025-02-17 23:04:38 +0000 UTCI chose the third one just instead of making for region make word it’s better And i hope you read the best cultivation novel fate destroying emperor to get some ideas
Sevensins
2025-02-17 22:28:15 +0000 UTCbro hasnt read western novels? bros gotta read brandon sanderson do how one piece does it, where different regions have different cultures.
rain
2025-02-17 22:15:21 +0000 UTCYou could make it so that the cultures from higher realms have trickled down into the lower realms (or vice versa) so that the same cultures could be used in the different realms
Diametric
2025-02-17 22:04:27 +0000 UTCin this being from Eastern Europe the writer only uses Eastern European names https://www.webnovelpub.pro/novel/mother-of-learning-30071448
Zaoprimo
2025-02-17 22:03:10 +0000 UTCThe only semi-cultivation western novel I know is probably Birth of the demonic sword. The author used western names.
BLazeSavage
2025-02-17 22:02:07 +0000 UTC